Skip to content

Your best campaign may be the one with the worst cost per lead

Cost per lead penalizes brand and reach campaigns, which work before the conversion. See where to look for their effect and the risk of cutting them.

Published on

5 min read

3D icon of a relay baton with motion lines, on a black, blue and pink gradient background with a dot texture

Cost per lead measures how much a campaign spends to generate each form, and that is why it penalizes brand and reach campaigns, which work before the conversion. Their work shows up later, in searches for the company name and in the lead who arrives already knowing the brand. Judged by CPL alone, the brand campaign is usually the first to be cut, and the effect shows up weeks later in the other campaigns.

Google itself measures this type of campaign by other criteria. The Google Ads help page on Brand Lift describes the tool as a way to measure video ads by ad recall, brand awareness, and consideration, instead of clicks or impressions.

Why cost per lead penalizes the brand campaign

CPL divides the investment by the leads the campaign generated directly, and the brand campaign is rarely the last touch before the form. It appears at the beginning of the journey: the person sees a video, remembers the name, and weeks later searches for the company on Google. The lead comes in through the search campaign, which gets the credit and the low CPL.

  • The objective is different: the brand campaign is optimized for reach or views, and the form is a consequence.
  • The credit goes to whoever closes: in last click, the conversion goes to the ad that was in front at the time of the form.
  • The timing does not match: the effect takes weeks, and the CPL report closes within the month.

This bias is well known. Last-click often rewards the brand search ad and remarketing, which harvest demand that another channel built, as we explained in the article about the attribution model.

Where to look for the effect of the brand campaign

The effect of the brand campaign shows up in three places that the CPL report does not show. All three depend on comparing periods with and without the campaign running.

  1. Searches for the company name: compare the volume of brand searches, in the Google Ads search terms report or in Search Console.
  2. Conversion of leads who already knew the company: separate the leads who arrive through brand search or direct traffic and compare their progression to opportunity with that of the others.
  3. Time to sale: compare the sales cycle of those leads with that of leads who arrived through a direct conversion campaign.

None of these numbers proves causation on its own. Together, they show whether the brand campaign is feeding the rest of the funnel. When cross-referencing platform and CRM, remember that Meta Ads data does not match the CRM because each system counts the journey with its own rules.

Resource · In PortuguesePrompt Guide for Marketing and Sales70 prompts with questions about marketing, sales and behavior to ask your data.Download the guide

The risk of cutting campaigns by cost per lead

When the brand campaign is cut because of CPL, the bottom-of-funnel campaigns may get worse weeks later, with nobody connecting the decline to the cut. A bottom-of-funnel campaign is one that captures people who are already ready to buy, such as brand search and remarketing. With fewer people knowing the company, there is less demand left for them to capture.

Imagine a hypothetical operation in which the video campaign has a CPL of R$ 300 and the brand search has R$ 40. The video is cut in March. In April, brand search continues with a low CPL, but the volume of searches drops and the total number of leads drops with it.

Les Binet and Peter Field already warned about this type of decision in the study The Long and the Short of It, published by the IPA, the British institute of advertising agencies. For the authors, using very short-term metrics as the main measure of performance carries dangerous implications for long-term results.

The same reasoning applies to the signal sent to the platforms. Optimizing only for the cheapest lead pulls the investment toward the audience that fills out forms, as we showed when explaining how to optimize the campaign for sales.

How to present the role of each campaign without depending on the last click

Present each campaign by the work it does in the funnel: generating demand, capturing demand, or converting. That way, leadership compares campaigns with the same role.

  • Brand and reach campaigns: reach among the right audience, brand searches, and new leads on first click.
  • Capture campaigns, such as search and remarketing: cost per lead and cost per opportunity.
  • All campaigns, in the end: cost per sale and revenue, read in the two attribution models side by side.

Reading in two models resolves a good part of the discussion. In first click, the brand campaign appears as the origin of customers; in last click, brand search appears as the one that closed. Campaign attribution is complete when the meeting sees both numbers together.

A paid media report that ends in a decision helps organize this format by campaign. If marketing's goal is written only in CPL, it is also worth reviewing how your operation's marketing and sales goals are defined.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good cost per lead?

It depends on how much that lead turns into a sale. A high CPL with good progression to opportunity can end up cheaper in cost per sale than a low CPL with a lead who does not buy.

What is the difference between branding and performance in paid media?

Branding campaigns work so that more people know and remember the brand, and the effect shows up over time. Performance campaigns seek conversion now and are measured by cost per lead or per sale.

How do you measure a brand campaign?

Track searches for the company name, new leads on first click, and the conversion of those who already knew the brand, comparing periods with and without the campaign. For video on Google, Brand Lift measures recall, awareness, and consideration.

To calculate the cost per lead, cost per opportunity, and cost per sale of each campaign, download the Laiki Metrics Guide, with the formula and an example for each indicator.

Share

Related content

Never make another decision in the dark

We set up your data operation alongside you and get your team ready to decide. Book a conversation and try it with your own data.